Background: in 1998, the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA) was voted into law and went into effect in 2000 due to the tireless efforts of Senator Edward Markey (D-MA). It’s goals were to:
- Prevent the online collection of personal information by persons or entities under age 13 living anywhere, globally, if the company is U.S.-based,
- Detail requirements for privacy policies,
- Explain when and how to seek verifiable consent from a parent or guardian, and
- Rules related to marketing to children <13.
In 1998, an APP was something you completed so that you could go to college. In 1998, the only computers in homes were large devices with 1GB hard drives, and 15” monitors. In 1998, we’re still two years before Xanga, five years before MySpace, six years before “thefacebook.com” first became available to just Harvard students, and nine years before the very first iPhone was released.
And, 21 years later, COPPA is STILL the primary law that protects children online. It’s woefully outdated and does not address today’s digital risks.
In December, the Federal Trade Commission, which is the wing of the US government responsible for COPPA and COPPA enforcement, asked for public comments about the Act and what changes, if any, should be made. Many child advocates like PYE are concerned that the FTC is beginning to feel pressure from Big Tech companies who would love greater access to data.
Protect Young Eyes has made it a strategic priority to focus on changing or creating laws to provide greater protections for children.
We submitted the following statement to the FTC explaining why age 13 isn’t old enough. Do you agree? Please let us know in the comments how you feel.
[divider style=”double” border=”small” color=”#1e73be”]
COPPA Rule Review, 16 CFR part 312, Project No. P195404
Dear Chairman Simons, Commissioner Phillips, Commissioner Chopra, Commissioner Slaughter, and Commissioner Wilson:
The Federal Trade Commission (“FTC” or “Commission”) has requested public comments related to its implementation of the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (“COPPA” or “the Act”), through the Children’s Online Privacy Protection Rule (“COPPA Rule” or “the Rule”). This Act provides children and families with critical privacy safeguards. Since passing COPPA in 1998, the FTC wisely approved revisions to the COPPA Rule in 2012 to broaden the definition of protected information in order to keep pace with technology advancements.
At Protect Young Eyes, our greatest concern is that recent comments and actions from the FTC seem to indicate that the interests of giant tech companies outweigh the interests of our precious children. And, we do not believe that large technology organizations can be trusted to look out for what’s best for our sons and daughters. Only strong laws, strongly enforced, with strong penalties will do anything to deter corporate behavior that prioritizes profits over protection.
Technology companies clearly recognize that children represent big money on their platforms. YouTube’s top revenue grossing star is a 7-year-old named “Ryan” for his toy reviews. Instagram and Snapchat are used by 75% and 76% of US teens respectively. Giant tech companies want information about our children. It’s up to you to protect them.
Parents can only do so much. The ubiquity of technology demands a joint effort from well-intentioned parents, law makers, and the enforcers of those laws. And with technologies that are becoming increasingly smarter and more godlike, it’s imperative that all three work harder than ever to protect our children from an increasingly hostile online world.
- Parents must have persistent and consistent conversations with their children about online harms.
- Lawmakers must create laws that are stronger and not weaker. Laws that speak to risks in 2019 and emerging risks.
- Those who enforce the laws must create greater deterrents so that corporate behavior actually changes.
To quote the comment letter submitted by the honorable Senators Markey, Blumenthal, Hawley, and Blackburn to the FTC on October 4, 2019:
“…the FTC’s failure now and in recent years to fully enforce COPPA compliance has us concerned that an update at this time could diminish children and parents’ control of their data or otherwise weaken existing privacy protections. Now is not the time to pull back. As children’s use of technology continues to increase, so too does the appetite by tech giants for children’s personal information. Your agency’s obligation is to put consumers’ interests first and enforce the law.”
We fully agree with this statement.
In comments recently reported by the Wall Street Journal, Senator Markey said that making 13 the age of digital adulthood was too young based on the digital risk present in 1998, but it was the best he could do under pressure from e-commerce companies who wanted to maintain access to a lucrative teen market.
How much more advanced and manipulative are the technologies in place today? Don’t our children deserve more protections and not fewer? If in 1998, COPPA was deemed minimally adequate to address 1998’s digital risks, then how can it possibly be adequate to address 2019’s digital risks? We must do more and not less.
Let kids be kids for just a little while longer.
It was Senator Markey back in March 2019 who said, “In the 21st century, we need to pass bipartisan and bicameral COPPA 2.0 legislation that puts children’s well-being at the top of Congress’s priority list. If we can agree on anything, it should be that children deserve strong and effective protections online.”
We agree with the legislation introduced in March 2019 by Senators Edward J. Markey (D-Mass.) and Josh Hawley (R-Mo.) prohibiting internet companies from collecting personal and location information from anyone under 13 without parental consent and from anyone 13- to 15-years old without the user’s consent. We also concur with the creation of an “Eraser Button,” allowing parents and kids to delete personal information instantly, and a “Digital Marketing Bill of Rights for Minors” that limits the collection of personal information. We also agree with the bill’s recommendation that a Youth Privacy and Marketing Division be created at the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), responsible for addressing the privacy of children and minors and marketing directed at children and minors.
Now is the time for stronger protections for children, not weaker ones. Your decision will echo into millions of homes across our great country for years. Our precious children are counting on you to protect them.
[divider style=”double” border=”small” color=”#1e73be”]
Chris McKenna, Founder: A man with never ending energy when it comes to fighting for the safety and protection of children. Chris practices his internet safety tips on his four amazing children and is regularly featured on news, radio, and podcasts for his research. His 2019 US Senate Judiciary Committee testimony was the catalyst for draft legislation and on-going discussion that could radically change online child protection laws and earned PYE the NCOSE Dignity Defense Alert Award in 2020. The PYE team has performed over 1,300 presentations at schools, churches, and nonprofits and was featured in the Childhood 2.0 movie. When not leading PYE, Chris is the Digital Marketing Manager for Covenant Eyes. Other loves include running, spreadsheets, nature, and candy.