When it comes to Android versus Apple, the age-old question from parents is, “which one is better for my kid?” There are definitely pros and cons.
Honestly, it’s really close. If your child is big into social media and you have concerns about how he/she is using it, then an Android device is going to allow for much better monitoring.
Protect Young Eyes promotes a 3-layer approach for creating a safer internet experience on all portable, digital devices.
Remember, where kids use technology often dictates how they use their technology. We have strong opinions about controlling where kids use their tech.
Related post: The 4 Worst Places for a Kid to be Online
Remember, you are responsible for every digital click on your home’s network, and so for every device that uses your home’s WIFI network, have something in place to monitor who’s connected to your WIFI and control where they’re going. Two popular options for parents are:
We’ve recently found OpenDNS to be glitchy with our internet service, which is why we’ve moved to Clean Browsing’s clean DNS for every device in our home, including the router.
Remember, the device will often be using a data plan or be connected to a wireless network that is not under your control.
In 2017, Google released Family Link, which is their own version of Apple’s Restrictions for controlling how a device is used. Family Link is available for anyone under 18, but lacks some of the flexibility we would like to see with middle and high school users. The most recent update to the app extended its supervision features to kids aged 13-18.
Here are the current Family Link features on both platforms:
Related post: Family Link Now Works on Chromebooks!
1. On your own parental device, download the Family Link app from your app store (Google Play for Android or App Store on iPhones). Even though you can only control an Android device used by a child or teen, the parent can use the Family Link app from either an Apple or Android device.
(Family Link App Icon)
2. Follow the three steps given by Google. At step two, you’ll be asked to create your child’s Google Account. This would be the only place where allow you to create a Gmail account for a child who is under 13. For a child who is 13+, he/she can create an account through the normal Google channels and simply attach it to the Family Link set-up below.
But, here’s the problem. So many kids have school email accounts where all of their school work is located in a Google Drive. Because Family Link requires you to create a Gmail account for your <13-year-old child, or use an existing Gmail account if your child is >13, your child can’t get to that school account.
FAQ: “My child has a school account. Can I use that to set up their Family Link account?”
Answer: No. Not currently. You must create a new account for your child. This ends up being a HUGE deterrent for parents and we hope Google removes this barrier, soon.
Related: Google’s Family Link Support page.
3. Pay for your Family Link account. This happens during step 2. Don’t worry – it only costs $0.01. Google does this to ensure you’re an adult that has a credit card to pay for the account.
4. Note – as you go through the Family Link set-up will also receive a series of emails for (1) Creating a Family, (2) Informing you about Family Link features, and (3) confirming your $0.01 payment. You can add more family members later, too, from the Family Link app.
5. Click the 3 horizontal lines in the upper left of the Family Link app. From there, click “Family Group” and then “Supervise family member” as shown in images (1) and (2) below. Google will ask you whether or not he/she has an existing Gmail account. If not, they’ll walk you through establishing one. If the child already has a Gmail account, you’ll type it in and be walked through a series of set-up steps. These set-up steps will look slightly different depending on whether or not the child is age <13 or 13-18.
6. (If setting up Family Link for a teenager’s Android) Go get your child’s device and download the Family Link for Teens app, which is shown in image (3) below. Open it up and with the parent and child devices side-by-side, follow the set-up steps, starting on each with what is shown on images (4) and (5) below. The interesting part here is that if the child is age 13-18, Google goes out of its way to let the teenager know on his/her device that there’s a parent who is trying to supervise their device. And “are you sure” is asked multiple times on multiple screens.
7. Once the set-up steps are complete, then the parent can browse the available controls in the Family Link app on their phone (iPhone or Android) and there are quite a few. This is shown in images (6) and (7) below.
YouTube Note: For your child <13 who uses Family Link on their Android device, regular YouTube isn’t available and kids are forced to watch YouTube Kids. If a teen is using Family Link, >13, then it’s up to the parent to control the YouTube app by setting Restricted Mode (unfortunately, on mobile, you can’t lock in the Restricted Mode setting).
Related Post: YouTube Restrictions Set-Up
BONUS: if you’re interested in receiving Family Link news directly from Google when new features are released, you can subscribe here.
There are a few great options:
**Don’t forget about possibly using a free, clean DNS service on the Android device! You can lock in a DNS that blocks porn, as we show in our detailed blog post below.